This article contains some information that might not be reliable, or is only based off assumption.
Reason: Some of the icons are missing their credits.
Icons and Thumbnails are preview images that serve as a preview of a specific game. When the main Regretevator game is updated, a new icon is usually shown for the remainder of the update's duration, however in some cases, an icon is replaced whilst an update is still in duration as well.
This page will list every icon that has been shown throughout 2023 and 2025, alongside some with unknown dates and icons from Regretevator Experimental. This list will also include game thumbnails, though those will only include ones that are on the main game only.
April 12th, a game icon of a happy Melanie with both hands shown to the viewer, reused from 11/30/24. This icon was temporarily seen for a short time before the release of the 4/12/24 update, until it was changed to the current icon.
April 1st, a game icon of PartyNoob as Mason Troy Adams, with caption saying "Regretevator" in place of the normal logo. This icon was reverted after April 2nd.
March 30th, a game icon of a shocked Melanie with several bunnies from Dying Mall.
March 25th, it's the same icon as the previous, but after The Hunt ended, where the custom frames are now gone.
March 13th, a game icon of a joyous PartyNoob, which was used during The Hunt: Mega Edition.
March 1st, a game icon of Folly. Althrough the icon was changed, there were no updates added to the game. (Art by @fishiistixx)
February 15th, a game icon of NULL menacingly staring into the viewer, with one of its eyes shining.
February 1st, a game icon of Two from Battle For Dream Island wearing PartyNoob's hat and holding a Red Teddy to the viewer.
January 11th, a game icon of Scag holding Floppies.
July 27th, a game icon of PartyNoob throwing their arm up in joy, with barely visible fangs on its mouth. Sebastian can be seen in the background. This icon was the winner of a game picture competition that started in July 23rd.
July 20th, a game icon of Pest holding a diamond in front of a background appearing to look like Temple of, Something.
July 13th, a game icon of Jeremy breaking into the elevator, reused from 8/7/2023. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
July 6th, a game icon of Split as an upcoming/unreleased design speaking, white speech bubbles surround her while her arm hangs over the dark purple border of the icon. (Artwork by @fishiistixx on X and Discord)
June 29th, a game icon of PartyNoob holding a present while raising their arm, referencing their ability to open a present after entering the elevator. (Artwork by @fishiistixx on X)
June 15th, a game icon of Gnarpy jumping out of the icons border, looking at the camera sinisterly. (Artwork by @fishiistixx on X and Discord)
June 8th, a game icon of Bive with her having claw-like hands and grasping onto the Regretevator logo, grinning with her mouth wide open. (Artwork by @fishiistixx on X and Discord)
June 1st, a game icon of Folly doing a shushing motion, with eyes surrounding her. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
May 25th, a game icon of Lampert adjusting the camera for the icon. (Artwork by @fishiistixx on X and Discord)
May 18th, a game icon of SlimYim looking forward in a blue background with a lighter blue spiral on it, along with a red, fleshy border. (Artwork by @LOBOTOLOID on X)
May 11th, a game icon of DrRETRO with her mouth wide open, with a comical green speech bubble on top of her, referencing the introduction of said NPC getting dialogue. (Artwork by @fishiistixx on X and Discord)
May 4th, a game icon of Reddy approaching the viewer to jumpscare them, with green paint stains in the background. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
April 27th, Prototype's head is seen in front of a dark blue sea-like background, winking and smiling, with several fruits and a realistic water splash around him. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
April 23rd, similar to the one used in April 20th, but instead shows Scag's idle face, the background gradient is slightly modified, and now uses a slightly lighter shade of blue.
April 20th, a game icon of one of Scag's TV screen faces when the Petal Cone is used on her. In this variant, her mouth is wide open and smiling.
April 13th, a game icon of Buck facing into the viewer. It's placed in front of a yellow background with circular stripes of a darker shade, referencing the introduction of the item with the same name.
April 6th, a game icon of Infected resting on the borders of the art, at the time CRUMBL CUBE was introduced. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
April 1st, a game icon of GorillaWeb depicted as a medieval painting. This was only used during the 2024 April Fools' Update, before returning to the March 31st one afterwards. This icon is now only used in the April Ghouls' Regretevator.
March 31st, a game icon of Pest holding a golden egg, as well as a brown woolen basket with many other variously-colored eggs placed inside. (Artwork by @fishiistixx on X and Discord)
March 23rd, a game icon of Jaoba staring into the camera, referencing the introduction of them.
March 16th, a game icon of Split with her hand out, laughing in joy. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
March 9th, a game icon of Prototype facing foward and smiling with his tongue out, referencing the introduction of him.
March 3rd, a game icon of Gnarpy hovering over a depiction of Earth, referencing the introduction of xyr redesign. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
Probably around February 24th, a game icon of the removed Miché standing in a children's ballpit from Tumblr Ballpit. (Artwork by @ztarzhark on Discord)
Probably around February 17th, a game icon of Yum Zlurplie in closeup. (Render by @DaftCinderss on X and Discord)
December 31st, a game icon of Gnarpy's old design in joy, with fireworks exploding on the background. This is a reference to the time 2024 started. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
Probably around December 24th. A game icon of Spud!, wearing a Santa hat and a red bowtie. (Artwork by @weenybumm on X/@weenybum on Discord)
December 16th, a game icon of Mannequin Mark and Wallter pushing each other away. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
December 9th, a game icon of Lampert smiling with his bulb on, a few pink and yellow flowers are surrounding him.
December 2nd, a game icon of Pilby depressed with their hands on their face. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
November 26th, a game icon of Pest, staring into the camera with their eyebrow raised. (Artwork by @weenybumm on X/@weenybum on Discord)
November 18th, a game icon of Spud! facing foward while standing. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
November 11th, a game icon of Infected looking noticeably zombie-like. (Artwork by @weenybumm on X/@weenybum on Discord)
Probably around November 4th. A game icon of Enphoso smiling with its mouth open, one of its eyes are mishapen and noticeably larger. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
October 14th, a game icon of Infected reaching out of the icons border while smiling. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
October 7th, a game icon of PartyNoob holding an orange pumpkin candy basket. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
September 30th, a game icon of PartyNoob doing a pose and winking with a happy expression on their face. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on Twitter and Discord)
September 20th, a game icon of Reddy waving with its mouth open. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
September 10th, a game icon of Split doing a peace sign with her hand while smiling. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
August 7th, a game icon of Jeremy breaking into the elevator. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
July 18th, a game icon of DrRETRO, having crazed eyes and her tongue sticking out. Animal Jam emojis can also be seen in the background. (Artwork by @KindaGlumm on X and Discord)
Probably around June 20th. A game icon of Pest with his oldest face and the new black upper shade with his eyes glowing, in closeup.
Ditto, but at another angle with a blue party horn.
A game icon of Gnarpy's old design, having a smug smile.
January 13th 2024, a game icon for Regretevator Experimental of Mannequin Mark in dark wood texture holding a hammer, red text that says "REGRETEVATOR TESTING" is shown on the top and bottom of it, with the upper one engulfed in flames. (Artwork by @weenybumm on X/@weenybum on Discord)
December 20th 2023, an older game icon for Regretevator Testing, with a real-life picture of an orange cat sitting on a pile of New Super Mario Bros game case boxes in a bathtub. It used the same text appearance.
Regretevator has some custom thumbnails that appear when you go to it's specified game page. It contains various screenshots of the actual game as well as custom artwork.
A thumbnail taking place in WHEEL OF with the incinerators after the wheel landed on DEATH. Players can be seen enjoying each other.
Another thumbnail that takes place in WHEEL OF, except the incinenators are blowing fire.
A thumbnail taking place inside the elevator, with several players enjoying each other, including Mannequin_Mark. However, all of the player's faces are censored.
Two, Robot Flower, and PartyNoob in object form taking center stage, a plethora of other BFDI pairings in the background. Pest can even be seen in object form. (February 1st, 2025)